It won't do to dream of caramel,
to think of cinnamon
and long for you
~Suzanne Vega~
Car-mel, cara-mel, caramel, however you pronounce it, this must be the thing the angels serve up in Heaven. Dear God, one silky spoonful of this sauce, and you will never, I promise you, never buy the store bought stuff again. I have seen the light and it's golden.
I've had this recipe tucked away in a folder since 2005, when I first sampled it on Martha's Vineyard. Shame on me for waiting 5 years to make it. A big shout-out to Amy Miller, a family friend, and professionally trained pastry chef who specializes in cakes, pastry and all things chocolate. A reliable source tells me that Amy's grandfather was the head chocolatier (I don't know if that's a real word) at Hershey's. Now that's some serious confectionary credibility right there.
I love that this recipe uses lemon juice. The acidity of the lemon cuts the sweetness that can often be cloying in many caramel sauces, and brightens the flavor considerably.Just a gentle squeeze from half a lemon will do it.
This recipe calls for salted butter. I generally only have unsalted butter on hand, so I improvised with sea salt. How do I love thee salt?
Use a wooden spoon while cooking the syrup. Metal conducts heat and this concoction is like molten lava.
Keep the syrup at a gentle boil and watch carefully as it begins to turn golden.
I used a metal spoon so the camera would pick up the color, but stick with wood!
Now the syrup has turned a deep golden color. Watch it carefully and rely on your sense of smell as well as your eyes to avoid scorching the sugar, which would make it bitter and un-tasty.
Okay, let me tell you, it was NOT easy to pour cream into molten sugar while taking the picture. I got lucky with this one!
I made sundae's for my kids, but this caramel sauce can be served warm or cool on just about anything - use your imagination.
Caramel Sauce (Adapted from Amy Miller's original recipe)
- 1 cup sugar
- 1/2 cup water
- Squeeze of lemon juice
- 1/2 cup salted butter (or unsalted butter with 1/2 tsp. sea salt)
- 3/4 cup heavy cream
- Boil the syrup till it begins to turn golden around the edges.
- Lower the heat a bit, continue boiling to a deep golden color; it will darken rapidly.
- Meanwhile, combine and heat the butter and cream until warm and melted.
- Remove from the heat. Slowly, carefully add butter and cream - it will sputter and spatter up - Beware!
- Return to low heat, stir until completely melted and smooth.
- Cool and serve hot or chilled.